Why Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organisation goes further than merely overturning Roe v Wade

The US Supreme Court decision in Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organisation (this organisation is based in the US state of Mississippi, of which Jackson is the state capital), which critically has the effect of overturning Roe v Wade [1973] (which guaranteed a constitutional right for women to have abortions) and Planned Parenthood v Casey, meaning that many 

Although it is a decision concerning the rights of unborn children and the rights of women, it goes wider than that. Here is why:

1. It is reflective of a polarised and divided society that could split in the near future. The majority of US states with "trigger laws" surrounding significant abortion restrictions are south of Washington DC; the majority of US states that still retain the death penalty are also south of Washington DC (and those states with the strictest abortion laws in the USA are amongst those who have carried out the most executions since Gregg v Georgia [1976], making a mockery of any pro-life claims of theirs). Furthermore, all of the US states which have trigger laws that will now come into effect are strongly Republican in terms of their legislature and the Senate, with virtually no hope of a change in that status, whereas the US states with the most liberal laws on abortion are strongly Democrat (or otherwise progressive, in Vermont's case) and are not likely to elect Republican legislatures anytime soon. The events of the last few years show that the USA could in the near future split along the Mason Dixon line, even if only ipso facto, and so could other societies for that matter.

2. It will trigger reverberating effects elsewhere in the world. Already in the European Union, Hungary and Poland (strongly Catholic and which were both once behind the Iron Curtain) have been taking a hardline stance on social matters, and not just regarding abortion restrictions either; other European nations could follow suit. For example, Croatia, where abortion is legal yet where most of the population is Catholic, has seen significant pro-life protests recently and many doctors there are refusing to carry out abortions. Also, more liberal nations will face increasing pressure to further liberalise their abortion laws to the point where abortion is legal at any stage of pregnancy and for any reason (as is the case in Canada, for instance).

3. It sows the seeds for other rights being rolled back in the USA. The decision to overturn Roe v Wade happened first and foremost because of the US Supreme Court's make-up: 6 Republicans and 3 Democrats. (The UK Supreme Court, thankfully, is not divided on partisan lines at all because of the existence of the Judicial Appointments Commission and the strict requirements for political impartiality) Voting rights, legal protections for the indigent etc. will also be significantly under threat in the USA as a result-and as mentioned above, this will likely result in similar effects somewhere across the Atlantic.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My analysis of local by-elections from 22/11/18

Readers, the results of this week's British local by-elections were as follows: Enfield LBC, Bush Hill Park: Conservative 1540 (52.4%, +12.7%), Labour 828 (28.2%, -8.3%), Liberal Democrats 313 (10.7%, -0.8%), Green 127 (4.3%, -6.6%), WEP 79 (2.7%), Independent (Oyaloyu) 50 (1.7%). [UKIP did not stand] Westminster LBC, Lancaster Gate: Conservative 913 (47.2%, -1.5%), Labour 684 (35.4%, -1.0%), Liberal Democrats 275 (14.2%, -0.7%), Green 62 (3.2%). Windsor & Maidenhead UA, Datchet: Conservative 525 (56.0%, -3.1%), National Flood Prevention Party 223 (23.8%), Labour 121 (12.9%, -9.1%), Liberal Democrats 48 (5.1%,-13.8%), Green 21 (2.2%). Wirral MBC, Upton: Labour 1490 (61.3%, +3.1%), Conservative 705 (29.0%, +0.4%), Green 151 (6.2%, -0.5%), Liberal Democrats 83 (3.4%, -0.8%). [TUSC did not stand] All changes are since May. The open divisions in the Conservatives, which resulted in a failed attempt to call for a vote of no confidence in Theresa May by the European Researc...
Read more

On the 2020 Serbian election: Why a boycott will only worsen things there

First of all, I apologise for the recent hiatus; however elections are still postponed or on hold in many countries, including the UK. Serbia, however, was able to proceed with its 2020 general election amidst this crisis. Its overall result proved reminiscent of Hungarian elections under Viktor Orban's tenure (2010-present), since the leading national-conservative coalition, the SNS (Progressive Party of Serbia) coalition led by Serbian President Aleksander Vucic (Ana Brnabic is the Serbian Prime Minister, and the first woman and openly homosexual person to hold that position), polled 61.6% of the vote, giving them as many as 191 seats out of 250 and a majority of as high as 132, almost unheard of in any country with proportional representation. Press freedom has endured significant curbs since President Vucic first came into power as Serbian PM in 2012 (he became President of Serbia in 2017), as have civil liberties of Serbs in general. Nepotism and corruption in the Serbian ...
Read more

On the French local elections of 2020: Vive le surge de vert!

The French local elections finally concluded yesterday, having been originally scheduled to take place on 15 March; they were postponed due to the effects of the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.  The most sensational story of these elections was the many triumphs by the main French Green Party, Europe Ecologie-Les Verts (EELV). In major French cities (those with more than 100,000 people), EELV captured the mayoralties of Annecy, Besancon, Bordeaux, Lyon, Marseille, Strasbourg, and Tours. They also performed impressively in the munciipal elections for those cities as well. However, in the midst of all this triumph there was one notable setback for them: Eric Pollie, the first Green Mayor of a major French city, decided to contest the mayoral election there as an "Independent Left" (divers gauche) candidate instead. Furthermore they narrowly missed out on unseating former PS leader Martine Aubry from her post as Mayor of Lille; in the second round she held on by 227 votes, a sig...
Read more